Avast ye! The Biden crew's Title IX plan be warned by a UN expert: 'Tis a treacherous path, be ware!
2023-12-28
Arr, on Wednesday, a learned soul o' the U.N. didst take a keen glance at the Biden administration's Title IX plan, and didst issue a dire caution 'bout the dreadful outcomes if 'tis put into action.
The Biden administration’s proposed Title IX rule changes, which would expand the definition of sexual discrimination to include gender identity and prevent schools from banning transgender athletes, faced criticism from a United Nations expert. Reem Alsalem, a U.N. special rapporteur on violence against women and girls, expressed concern that these changes would violate the rights of biological women and girls in sports. She stated that the proposed rule changes could result in the denial of fair competition and athletic opportunities for biological women, as well as the loss of privacy and increased risks of physical injury, harassment, and voyeurism. Alsalem argued that these changes would go against the United States’ international human rights obligations and commitments to prevent violence and discrimination against women and girls.Under the Education Department’s proposed rule, schools or colleges that receive federal funding would not be allowed to implement policies that categorically ban transgender students from playing on sports teams consistent with their gender identity. The proposed rule seeks to clarify Title IX's application to sex-related criteria and ensure that schools develop eligibility criteria that protect students from being denied equal athletic opportunities while also allowing for some flexibility in policy development.
Education Secretary Miguel Cardona has expressed support for allowing biological male transgender individuals to compete in women's sports, emphasizing the importance of respecting the rights of all students. However, the U.N. expert warned that these proposed changes would contravene the United States’ obligations under international human rights law.
In conclusion, the Biden administration’s Title IX proposal has sparked concerns regarding the rights and opportunities of biological women and girls in sports. While the administration argues that the proposed changes aim to provide equal athletic opportunities for all students, critics argue that these changes could have detrimental effects on the participation and privacy of biological women and girls. The debate surrounding transgender inclusion in sports continues to be a contentious issue with implications for gender equality and human rights.